Author Archives: bo1nn

NERC funded PhD position on the role of butterfly wing scales in thermoregulation

We are seeking an enthusiastic student with interests in ecology and evolution to work on a project investigating the evolution of wing scale nanostructures and thermal adaptation in tropical Andean butterflies. The wings of butterflies are covered in thousands of scales that have evolved to serve a range of functions including aerodynamic efficiency, colour signalling, camouflage, hydrophobicity and thermoregulation. Fundamental to these functions is the nanostructure of the scales.

Interest in organisms’ adaptation to their thermal environment has grown in recent years as we try to understand and predict how organisms will respond to climate change. Butterflies are one of the best-studied insect groups with respect to thermal adaptation. While the importance of the wings for thermoregulation has been known for some time, only recently has the importance of the wing scale nanostructures begun to be appreciated.

The project can be tailored to the interests of the student but would likely include working with museum collections of butterflies at the Natural History Museum (under the supervision of Dr Huetas), using cutting-edge techniques for measuring scale nanostructure (under the supervision of Dr Parnell) and computational analysis to investigate ecological correlates of wing scale nanostructure (under the supervision of Dr Thomas). It could also involve fieldwork in South America to obtain further butterfly specimens, ecological data and/or test hypotheses about thermal adaptation. This project builds on recent work in Dr Nadeau’s research group investigating the evolution, genetics and development of butterfly wing scale nanostructures and thermal adaptation in tropical Andean butterflies. The outcomes of this project could have applications in the design of nanomaterials to improve the thermal efficiency of man-made structures such as windows and solar panels.

Application process

Informal enquiries are welcome. Contact Nicola Nadeau.

Follow the instruction to apply online here

Shortlisted applicants will be invited for an interview to take place in the w/c 22nd February 2021.

Funding Notes

ACCE NERC DTP in Ecology and Evolution, programme starting October 2021.

UKRI provide the following funding for 3.5 years:
• Research Council Stipend – at least £15,285 (UKRI rate for 2020/21)
• Tuition Fees at the UK fee rate (2020/21 rate £4,406)
• Research support and training grant (RTSG)

Please note that international and EU fee rate candidates would need to cover the remaining amount of tuition fees by securing additional funding. International and EU tuition fees for 2021 entry £23,750.
Not all projects will be funded; the DTP will appoint a limited number of candidates via a competitive process.

New publication! Convergent evolution of quantitative pattern variation

This research, published in the Journal of Evolutionary Biology, started out as Masters project by Hannah Bainbridge. She investigated vairation in the size and shape of the red band found on the wing of two butterfly species that mimic each other, Heliconius erato and Heliconius melpomene. These two species are known to use the same major-effect genes to control major differences in colour and pattern that are found between popualtions, but more subtle variation has not been investigated to the same extent. We find that this variation is also controlled by some of the same major-effect genes, but overall the two species largely seem to use different genes to control it.

Heat map of pattern variation in H. erato and H. melpomene
Variation in the size and shape of the red forewing band in H. melpomene (A) and H. erato (B). Brighter regions contain red in a higher proportion of individuals.

New publication! Clines in iridescent structural colour

We have a new paper out in Molecular Ecology where we investigate variation in iridescent structural colour in the mimetic butterflies Heliconius erato and Heliconius melpomene. Both of these species vary from having to blue iridescent colour in Colombia to being matt black in Panama.

In her PhD thesis work Emma Curran showed that the colour change is more gradual in H. melpomene than H. erato and this is most likely due to weaker selection acting on the colour in this species. She also investigated population genomic structure and fund that while H. erato clusters into two different groups in Panama and Colombia, H. melpomene doesn’t. While the colour change happens in a similar place in both species, strongly suggesting that mimicry between the species has been important in its evolution, the differences between species hint at different evolutionary histories.

This is the first time that variation in iridescent structural colour has been investigated in wild Heliconius populations. This trait is also different to the colour pattern traits that have most commonly been investigated in Heliconius because it is a quantitative trait, controlled by many loci, rather being controlled by a single genetic locus. Our results therefore also shed light on the major question of how differences in quantitative traits evolve.

New publication! Altitude and life‐history shape the evolution of Heliconius wings

We have a new paper out in Evolution about the effects of altitude and life history on wing size and shape in Heliconius butterflies. Work done by PhD student Gabriela Montejo‐Kovacevich, and former Masters student Jennifer Smith, shows that species found higher up the slopes of the Andes tend to have larger and rounder wings. We also found that in species with gregarious larvae, females were larger than males, while the opposite was the case for species with solitary larvae. This is the first publication from our NERC funded project on adaptation to altitude in tropical insects.

Jennie and Gabby (and Kathy) collecting butterflies in the Andes
Jennie and Gabby (and Kathy) collecting butterflies in the Andes

Congratulations Mel!

Congratulations to Mel Brien who submitted her PhD thesis in August, just in time to go and present her work at the ESEB Congress in Turku, Finland.

The lab hanging out with one of the residents of Moonin land at the ESEB congress dinner

New publication! Phenotypic variation in Heliconius erato crosses shows that iridescent structural colour is sex-linked and controlled by multiple genes

We have a new paper out in the Journal of the Royal Society, Interface Focus, as part of a special issue on structural colour. Mel has used the variation in iridescent blue colour that we see in crosses between blue and black subspecies of Heliconius erato, to investigate the genetics of this trait. She shows that it is controlled by multiple genes, one or more of which are located on the Z sex-chromosome. Juan also investigates how one aspect of scale structure (ridge spacing) varies in these crosses. He shows that closer ridge spacing produces brighter blue colour, and that this trait also appears to be controlled by several genes. This is the first investigation of the genetics of structural colour in Heliconius. In fact, very little is known about the genetic control of structural colour in any animal. We plan to follow up this work by investigating the molecular genetics of structural colour production in these butterflies.

Crosses in Heliconius erato

Congratulations Dr Curran!

Congratulations to Emma who successfully defended her thesis at the end of November. Mel made this amazing hybrid zone cake to celebrate. It (very accurately) shows the hybrid zone that Emma worked on for her thesis, where the butterflies go from being black (in the north) to blue (in the south).


NERC funded PhD position on temperature adaptation in Heliconius

We are seeking an enthusiastic student with interests in ecology, evolution and genetics to work on a project investigating thermal adaptation in tropical Andean butterflies. Understanding organisms’ adaptation to their thermal environment is important for predicting responses to climate change. Tropical insects make up around half of all species on Earth, and yet very little is known about their thermal ecology. Butterflies are one of the best-studied insect groups concerning thermal adaptation, but relatively little is known about the responses of tropical species to climate change.

The Heliconius butterflies have been extensively studied, and there is good information about the distributions of species in this genus, but very little is known about what determines species ranges (e.g. temperature versus rainfall), or how ranges have shifted. Many of the species in the genus are found in and around the Andes, and it seems likely that thermal adaptation plays a role in delimiting niches in this area, and in driving distributions to shift uphill, but this has not previously been investigated. Excellent genomic resources are available for Heliconius, which have been used to investigate genes underlying adaptation and speciation. This provides the opportunity to investigate thermal adaptation in this group at multiple levels, from genes to populations, species and communities, to investigate and predict responses to climate change.

The project can be tailored to the interests of the student but could include a combination of field work, physiological and genetic laboratory work, computational analysis including analysis of genomic data and species distribution modelling, and working with historical collections and records. Key questions that could be addressed include: understanding how temperature affects survival, growth and fecundity of Heliconius species found at different elevations across the Andes; if and how these parameters relate to species distributions and range limits; if and how species ranges are changing or could change in response to habitat and climate change; the genetic basis of thermal adaptation and whether genetic changes have occurred or are they likely to occur in response to climate change.

This PhD will be linked to a newly funded NERC grant exploring variation in thermal adaptation across altitudinal gradients in Heliconius and the genetic basis of this. This collaborative project is led by Dr Nadeau in Sheffield, with Prof. Jiggins in Cambridge, Dr Saastamoinen in Helsinki and Dr Bacquet at the Amazonian Regional University, IKIAM, in Ecuador. The PhD student will expand this work to understand the implications for species distributions and climate change, with guidance from co-supervisor Prof. Hill in York.

Application deadline: Wednesday 9th January, 2019

Apply via the online application system

  • Select ‘Standard PhD’ and ‘Animal and Plant Sciences (APS)’ as the department
  • Fill in the Title of the project (‘Understanding temperature adaptation in tropical Andean butterflies’) and the name(s) of the supervisors (‘Dr Nicola Nadeau and Prof. Jane Hill’).
  • ‘Study term,’ can be full-time or part-time
  • The starting date of PhD will be the start of the next academic year- 1 Oct 2019
  • Funding stage‘ on the form will be ‘project studentship

Contact Nicola Nadeau for informal enquiries and further information.

Funding Notes

Fully funded studentships cover: (i) a stipend at the UKRI rate (at least £14,777 per annum for 2019-2020), (ii) research costs, and (iii) tuition fees. Studentship(s) are available to UK and EU students who have been living in the UK for the last three years immediately before the start of the studentship. EU nationals who do not meet the residency requirement are still eligible for ‘fees only award’, which covers fees and a research grant (RTSG), but no stipend.
This PhD project is part of the NERC funded Doctoral Training Partnership “ACCE” (Adapting to the Challenges of a Changing Environment). ACCE is a partnership between the Universities of Sheffield, Liverpool, York, CEH, and NHM.
Shortlisted applicants will be invited for an interview to take place at the University of Sheffield the w/c 11th February 2019.

Further reading

Nadeau NJ et al. 2014 Population genomics of parallel hybrid zones in the mimetic butterflies, H. Melpomene and H. erato. Genome Res. 24, 1316–1333. DOI:10.1101/gr.169292.113
Scriven SA, Beale CM, Benedick S, Hill JK. 2017 Barriers to dispersal of rain forest butterflies in tropical agricultural landscapes. Biotropica 49, 206–216. DOI:10.1111/btp.12397
Rosser N, Phillimore AB, Huertas B, Willmott KR, Mallet J. 2012 Testing historical explanations for gradients in species richness in heliconiine butterflies of tropical America. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 105, 479–497. DOI:10.1111/j.1095-8312.2011.01814.x